(I was so happy when this happened)
Its been a long journey to get back to where I started before Episode VII came out. This isn’t a review of ‘Episode VII: The Force Awakens’, more an essay about the Star Wars franchise now. Short version – I enjoyed it.
EXPANDED UNIVERSE:
Star Wars had been a love of mine since I was too young to understand it. There are things I knew about it before I properly watched it. Darth Vader was the baddie but also Luke’s father. Luke’s best friend was the space pirate Han Solo. There was Princess Leia, Chewie and so on. I loved it. I read Star Wars magazine in my teens, I even bought into the idea of the ‘special edition’.
I read a lot of the books. I mean, most of them are awful and forgettable but the Timothy Zahn ones, The Dark Empire comics and a few others I enjoyed. There were some things that became established. Lucasfilm endorsed the books after all.
So Episode I comes around in 1997 and my first reaction was “it was okay.” I then reflected and reflected and Episodes II and III came around and I basically came to dislike the franchise as a whole.
It wasn’t just that Episodes II and III are bad, its just that I felt they betrayed me somehow. I have several books and went to exhibitions at the Barbican and exhibition centres about how the Star Wars saga was a modern interpretation of classic myth. That Lucas knew Joseph Campbell’s ‘hero with a thousand faces’ and was an epic dreamer reinterpreting mythology and classic storytelling through space drama and also bringing in all kinds of other influences. Then it turned out it wasn’t any of that. It was just co-incidence. Given free reign he would create ‘a firework display of a toy advert’. I stopped caring a great deal about Star wars.
Now flash forward to the build-up to Episode VII. I held a lot of trepidation (see below). I felt it was likely to be awful but I would still probably go see it.
As it is; Episode VII is actually a lot of fun. I sat in the cinema, a single tear down my cheek as the Resistance arrive over the lake and blaster fire starts and I thought (no I yelled in my mind);
“I’m enjoying this. This is how it should feel to watch ‘Star Wars’.”
Sure, it was hugely derivative but the characters were good and I cared about them and it was FUN! It felt a lot like they were smoothing ruffled feathers of fans who had been hurt before as well. As a result of all of the above I just forgave it of its flaws. Another thing that was refreshing was that I could watch it without having watched or read a bunch of other stuff (see General Grievous). There were just NEW characters and I knew what they were about (Snokes! Hux! Poe!). It was exciting! As I say, it feels like they were bringing things back to a good place so they can tell some new exciting stories in the universe.
LEGENDS:
Something didn’t sit right with me that the expanded universe was being disregarded
If any book or expanded universe material (like say Knights of the Old Republic) that came out before April 25th 2014 was no longer canon, what about all the things that have been taken from them and used in the films? Off the top of my head, ‘Coruscant’ and ‘Kashyyk’ planet names are from Timothy Zahn (though the concepts are from Lucas). Also, General Grievous featured in the Clone Wars cartoon but that is no longer canon. So even characters who appear in things around the prequels aren’t canon either. However, I can understand the need to draw a line under what has come before in order to free-up the film-makers.
Now, J.J. Abrams is a great film-maker and I have enjoyed some of his work. However, when he made Star Trek, having said he wasn’t a fan of Star Trek alarm bells rang. It’s an alright film and has the decency to establish a new continuity for the films (although some fans feel this is a slap in the face).
So when ‘Star Trek into darkness’ came along and saw him rip, wholesale, scenes from ‘Star Trek II: Wrath of Khan’ and plug them, out of context into the film I really turned on him. Now some, argue he is giving these scenes a new, exciting context and I can agree with that a bit but doesn’t it just undermine the original concept which was strong to begin with? What I mean is, you can take a poor idea and make it good or a poorly presented idea and make it better and more meaningful but can you just rip off a good idea without it just being derivative?
So imagine my terror when I realised what was about to happen. The Expanded universe was now free to plunder. I feared I would see great characters like Mara Jade, Grand Admiral Thrawn, Admiral Daala, Prince Isolder, Jacen and Jaina all ripped off and plugged poorly into the new film. As it is, we didn’t see re-imagined versions of EU characters and for that I can only be thankful.
HOWEVER. The dark side of this is still around. It seems that fan favorite Grand Admiral Thrawn will likely appear in the cartoon ‘Rebels’. No doubt, ripped off, out of context. It also means he could appear, ripped off and out of context potentially in another of the films. Maybe you have faith that Abrams will do him justice but I have seen ‘Star Trek into Darkness’ and I doubt it. Hopefully I will be proved wrong, just as I was with Episode VII.
P